Last checked with GitLab: . Status comes from GitLab using a 2-minute cache. Merge events clear affected cached statuses. An already-open page does not update itself. Refresh page.

An MR completes this bounty when it is merged into main with Closes #289 and GitLab closes the issue. A mention or an updated timestamp is not completion. Awarded points appear in Activity.

Submit a merge request that closes this issue to earn points on merge — bounties stack on the standard +40 merge_pr award. New to the repo? See the Contributing guide, and Local Development & SSO to run the app locally (cp .dev.vars.example .dev.vars && pnpm dev, after rebasing on main) and fully test your change before opening the MR.

Description

The research guides emphasize citations and competing hypotheses; add a practical exercise showing why several articles repeating one originating statement are not independent confirmations.

Who might enjoy this

  • Community interests: Research, Warfare studies, Community / knowledge sharing
  • Skills: docs, data
  • Experience: starter; work style: writing.
  • Readiness: ready; bounty size: S (existing points tier; standard merge award stacks separately).

Current behavior and starting points

Source-reviewed against main cf05b29c6256dba70d0ebc09b22cc9867cdb786a on2026-10-18. Check current main and related issues/MRs before implementing so existing work is reused.

Relevant Files

Deliverables

  • An original fictional packet of short source excerpts and a source-lineage table with publication time, origin and direct/derived status.
  • A learner worksheet and separate answer key distinguishing observation, quotation, repetition and assumption.

Dependencies and decisions

No prerequisite issue is required. Re-read current main and linked MRs before starting.

Acceptance criteria

  • [ ] At least six original synthetic excerpts trace to at least two independent origins; one circular citation and one contradictory datum are deliberate teaching cases.
  • [ ] Answer key links every conclusion to excerpt IDs and marks unresolved assumptions; it never scores repetition as independent corroboration.
  • [ ] A second reader completes the exercise using only the packet; wiki check/build passes with accessible tables and valid internal links.
  • [ ] Record named baseline failures and the exact commands used. A behavior fix includes a real route/database/protocol check observed failing before the change. Knowledge work includes source traceability and reproducible reviewer evidence.
  • [ ] Run the affected app's existing checks. Explain any baseline failures rather than reporting a matching failure count as proof.

Try it locally

Start from the existing source files above. The following is the target demo your contribution should enable; a newly proposed script or fixture is part of the deliverable:

Follow the source links in the fictional packet and compare your independence map with the answer key.

Use public or synthetic examples. Starter work should run without production access; explicitly name any software/device prerequisite before claiming it is ready.

Out of scope

  • No real member conversations, intelligence collection, ongoing conflict assessments or AI credibility scoring.
  • No general bibliography checker or full SAT rewrite.
  • Unrelated refactors, new services/providers, bulk dependency changes, production access changes, unrequested notifications, and copying private member material. Keep credentials and unresolved security findings outside the issue and repository.

For a coding agent and reviewer

Read AGENTS.md, applicable .cursor/rules/, app instructions and docs/contributing/agentic-bounty-review.md. Reuse the existing shared helpers, identity/access paths and app styling. Implement one bounded story and provide evidence the accepting app maintainer can reproduce. State updated / pre-release verified / released / live verified accurately.

A parent index carries no duplicate award for these child deliverables. Open one scoped MR using this issue's actual number after the closing keyword. Link your GitLab identity on Scoreboard; the existing merge webhook handles eligible points.

Catalog index: #258.

<!-- community-interest-bounty:2026-10-18:research-independent-evidence -->

Relevant files

Hints

No hints yet.

Activity

No points have been awarded for this bounty yet.

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to weigh in.

↑ Top